| 14.09.1895 | Loughborough | 3 | - | 3 | D | 3.000 | LgDiv2 | U | The Athletic Ground | Joe Cassidy x2, James McNaught | |||||
| 04.04.1896 | Loughborough | 2 | - | 0 | W | 4.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | Bob Donaldson, Richard Smith | |||||
| 06.02.1897 | Loughborough | 6 | - | 0 | W | 5.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | Richard Smith x2, Henry Boyd, Bob Donaldson, Levi Draycott, Ceaser Jenkyns | |||||
| 10.04.1897 | Loughborough | 0 | - | 2 | L | 3.000 | LgDiv2 | U | The Athletic Ground | ||||||
| 29.03.1898 | Loughborough | 5 | - | 1 | W | 2.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | Henry Boyd x3, Joe Cassidy x2 | |||||
| 16.04.1898 | Loughborough | 0 | - | 0 | D | 1.200 | LgDiv2 | U | The Athletic Ground | ||||||
| 22.10.1898 | Loughborough | 6 | - | 1 | W | 2.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | William Brooks x2, Joe Cassidy x2, James Collinson x2 | |||||
| 18.02.1899 | Loughborough | 1 | - | 0 | W | 1.500 | LgDiv2 | U | The Athletic Ground | Willie Bryant | |||||
| 16.09.1899 | Loughborough | 4 | - | 0 | W | 6.000 | LgDiv2 | H | Bank Street | James Bain, Joe Cassidy, William Griffiths, (o.g.) | |||||
| 13.01.1900 | Loughborough | 2 | - | 0 | W | 1.000 | LgDiv2 | U | The Athletic Ground | William Jackson, Robert Parkinson |