Liste over de kampe Manchester United har spillet som er kommet ud i forlænget spilletid eller er afgjort på reglen om udebane mål eller straffespark konkurrence.
30.10.1886 fac R1 Fleetwood Rangers away D 2-2 (Fleetwood Rangers won - Manchester United disqualified)
10.02.1894 fac R2 Blackburn Rovers home D 0-0 aet
16.12.1903 fac IRR Birmingham City away D 1-1 aet
21.12.1903 fac IRR2 Birmingham City neutral D 1-1 aet
18.01.1905 fac IRR Fulham away D 0-0 aet
14.03.1912 fac R4R Blackburn Rovers away L 2-4 aet
12.01.1927 fac R3R Reading home D 2-2 aet
14.01.1931 fac R3R Stoke City home D 0-0 aet
05.02.1949 fac R4R Bradford Park Avenue away D 1-1 aet
26.03.1949 fac SF Wolverhampton Wanderers neutral D 1-1 aet
04.03.1964 fac R6R Sunderland away D 2-2 aet
15.02.1966 fac R4R Rotherham United away W 1-0 aet
31.01.1968 fac R3R Tottenham Hotspur away L 0-1 aet
29.05.1968 ec F Benfica neutral W 4-1 aet
23.03.1970 fac SFR Leeds United neutral D 0-0 aet
05.08.1970 wat SF Hull City away D 1-1 aet (Manchester United won on penalties)
08.11.1971 lc R4R Stoke City away D 0-0 aet
19.01.1972 fac R3R Southampton home W 4-1 aet
22.03.1972 fac R6R Stoke City away L 1-2 aet
07.01.1975 fac R3R Walsall away L 2-3 aet
09.03.1976 fac R6R Wolverhampton Wanderers away W 3-2 aet
04.10.1976 lc R3R Sunderland away D 2-2 aet
01.02.1978 fac R4R West Bromwich Albion away L 2-3 aet
09.01.1980 fac R3R Tottenham Hotspur home L 0-1 aet
01.10.1980 uefa R1-2 Widzew Lodz away D 0-0 (Widzew Lodz won on away goals)
26.03.1983 lc F Liverpool neutral L 1-2 aet
21.05.1983 fac F Brighton and Hove A. neutral D 2-2 aet
27.09.1983 cwc R1-2 Dukla Prague away D 2-2 (Manchester United won on away goals)
07.12.1983 lc R4R Oxford United home D 1-1 aet
19.12.1983 lc R4R2 Oxford United away L 1-2 aet
07.11.1984 uefa R2-2 PSV Eindhoven home W 1-0 aet
20.03.1985 uefa QF-2 Videoton away L 0-1 aet (Videoton won on penalties)
13.04.1985 fac SF Liverpool neutral D 2-2 aet
18.05.1985 fac F Everton neutral W 1-0 aet
21.09.1988 ect SF Newcastle United home W 2-0 aet
11.01.1989 fac R3R Queens Park Rangers away D 2-2 aet
08.04.1990 fac SF Oldham Athletic neutral D 3-3 aet
11.04.1990 fac SFR Oldham Athletic neutral W 2-1 aet
12.05.1990 fac F Crystal Palace neutral D 3-3 aet
02.10.1991 ecw R1-2 Athinaikos home W 2-0 aet
05.02.1992 fac R4R Southampton home D 2-2 aet (Southampton won on penalties)
11.03.1992 lc sf-2 Middlesbrough home W 2-1 aet
30.09.1992 uefa R1-2 Torpedo Moscow away D 0-0 aet (Torpedo Moscow won on penalties)
07.08.1993 cs F Arsenal neutral D 1-1 (Manchester United won on penalties)
03.11.1993 cl R2-2 Galatasaray away D 0-0 (Galatasaray won on away goals)
10.04.1994 fac SF Oldham Athletic neutral D 1-1 aet
09.04.1995 fac SF Crystal Palace neutral D 2-2 aet
26.09.1995 uefa R1-2 Rotor Volgograd home D 2-2 (Rotor Volgograd won on away goals)
03.08.1997 cs F Chelsea neutral D 1-1 (Manchester United won on penalties)
18.03.1998 cl QF-2 Monaco home D 1-1 (Monaco won on away goals)
28.10.1998 lc R3 Bury home W 2-0 aet
11.04.1999 fac SF Arsenal neutral D 0-0 aet
14.04.1999 fac SFR Arsenal neutral W 2-1 aet
30.04.2002 cl SF-2 Bayer Leverkusen away D 1-1 (Bayer Leverkusen won on away goals)
10.08.2003 cs F Arsenal neutral D 1-1 (Manchester United won on penalties)
28.10.2003 lc R3 Leeds United away W 3-2 aet
21.05.2005 fn F Arsenal neutral D 0-0 aet (Arsenal won on penalties)
25.10.2006 lc R3 Crewe Alexandra away W 2-1 aet
19.05.2007 fac F Chelsea neutral L 0-1 aet
05.08.2007 sc F Chelsea neutral D 1-1 (Manchester United won on penalties)
21.05.2008 cl F Chelsea neutral D 1-1 aet (Manchester United won on penalties)
10.08.2008 cs F Portsmouth neutral D 0-0 (Manchester United won on penalties)
01.03.2009 lc F Tottenham Hutspur neutral D 0-0 (Manchester United won on penalties)
19.04.2009 fac F Everton neutral D 0-0 aet (Everton won on penalties)
09.08.2009 cs Chelsea neutral D 2-2 (Chelsea won on penalties)
07.04.2010 cl Bayern Munich QF-2 home W 3-2 (Bayern Munich won on away goal)